The 2022 Western mystery film centers on the brutal killing of a prospector in a declining Montana town and the subsequent rush to judgment against a newcomer. Plot Summary

: Sheriff Jim Ambrose (Gabriel Byrne) quickly arrests Cicero (Isaiah Mustafa), a former slave and newcomer who happens to be a fan of Shakespeare. Ambrose views him as the perfect scapegoat, claiming he is "the only man who doesn't know what [Ambrose will] do to him."

Reviewers generally describe the film as a "solid" but "slow-burn" blend of a traditional Western and an Agatha Christie-style whodunit. Murder at Yellowstone City - UpcomingDiscs.com

: While Cicero faces a trial, the town’s new minister, Thaddeus Murphy (Thomas Jane), and his wife Alice (Anna Camp) begin their own investigation. They discover that nearly everyone in town has a secret or a motive to kill Dunnigan.